STOREP CONFERENCES, STOREP 2016 - Engines of growth and paths of development in the minds of analysts, policy makers and human beings

Font Size: 
Unproductive capital and the long run tendency in the distribution of income and wealth: the analysis by Supino
massimo di matteo

Last modified: 2016-06-03

Abstract


During all his life Camillo Supino (1860-1931) was particularly interested in understanding the evolution of the capitalist system and more particularly the economic crises. He first (1898) wrote  “La borsa e il capitale improduttivo”  and shortly afterwards “Le crisi economiche” (1907); finally he came back to the topic in his last paper “Il capitale  immaginario” published in 1932 immediately after his death. In these works he analyzes the role and the effects of the unproductive capital on the production and distribution of wealth in the economic system. His work being written during the first globalization appears to be particularly interesting today.

There are four parts in the paper. In the first  a brief outline of Supino’s interpretation of crises is offered. Then the concept of unproductive capital (hence UK) is introduced and defined. His roots in the classical analysis are noted as well as the criticism towards Say’s law. The many ways in which capital changes from productive into unproductive are stressed. Thirdly the various forms in which UK manifests itself  in the financial sector are described in great detail and with attention to the technical issues of the stock market. Bonds and shares are given different treatment and the peculiarities of public  capital with respect to private are analyzed. He stresses that the interest on government bonds is ultimately paid by indirect taxes which are regressive. Finally a thorough  analysis of the many effects of UK on the distribution of income and wealth is provided. In turn these effects will change the structure of demand and  production  over the cycle and the long period. Supino argues that the growth in UK is a remedy towards the fall in profits while at the same time damaging workers by decreasing wages, both real and monetary, and increasing unemployment. The conclusion of the analysis is that capitalism is changing to a regressive form of organization following the gap between personal interest and social benefit.

In the ending remarks of the paper a general interpretation of Supino’s arguments in connection with the present debate on the long run tendency of wealth distribution is offered.


Keywords


unproductive capital; financial capital; distribution of income & wealth

Full Text: Paper Di Matteo